Home | Blag Index


From: wayne+blog@waynewerner.com
To: everyone.everywhere.all.at.once
Date: Tue, 10 Nov 2026 15:27:25 -0600
Subject: Google is Killing the Internet 

This post has been waiting for over 4 years. It's not getting any better.

Google is Killing the Internet

On Thursday, 2022-06-30, Wayne wayne+blog@waynewerner.com wrote:

A bold claim? Certainly! Is Google really killing the Internet? Maybe I'm wrong, but I don't think so.

Apparently it's been several years since I first started this draft. It feels insane, actually, that I have been thinking about this topic for long enough to start the draft four years ago, which means that I've been thinking about the topic for at least that long but in all reality probably way longer. Woof.

In 2026 we're used to all kinds of computing and connectivity and all sorts of social networking and media consumption.

But computers didn't always used to be like that.

This was the very first webpage there ever was. Look familiar? I wrote a little about this a while ago. But the very basic idea of the original World Wide Web was that you could click on links and navigate from here to there and use your browser's back button, at least, to get back again. This kind of information storage and retrieval system is ridiculously powerful. You may be old enough to remember that this is just how the heck we surfed the web, finding new and interesting things to read or interact with.

I'm going to tell you a story, but here's the rest of that original draft:

There's an enormous power in this simplicity. It's almost immediately accessible. It's small, it's lightweight, it's fast. Using Pingdom just to load google.com it loads 822.1KB and makes 37 requests. It probably loads a few more MB in Javascript while it's at it. Loading my main page takes 3.9KB and requires 3 requests. I'm also not tracking you.

In the early days of the Internet, (1977 to be precise, though 1982 is definitely closer to what we think of today), the STANDARD FOR THE FORMAT OF ARPA NETWORK TEXT MESSAGES(1) was defined. This was the foundation of the e-mail messages that drive your life today. It predates the gopher protocol by more than a decade, which itself predated the HTTP protocol that all of modern life is built on.

The Internet mostly grew up in the environments of Academia, and didn't need security because nobody was banking with it or doing anything else. That eventually changed into what we see today. But in those days there was no reason to send spam because there was nobody out there. Eventually your ISP probably would run a mail server, and especially AOL. This method of being able to send communication directly to other individuals throughout the Internet, regardless of where they lived or how often they were online was a massive shift in the way we interacted.

Our story begins sometime in the 1970s. There were a lot of technologists excited about the future of computing. Computers were changing from giant vacuum tube machines that took up an entire room and require punch cards to program into true, general purpose computing devices. In 1969 in AT&T's Bell Labs they started working on a multi-user computer system called Unix. That wasn't the first multi-user system, of course.

In business and in universities people were communicating for all kinds of things. Not that this was anything particularly novel of course - for decades anyone who was interested in learning would write letters to each other and to different groups they were a part of. There were whole snail-mail based math dramas that were absolutely on par with any modern Internet drama.

But now instead of copying things by hand, we had computers that multiple people could access at the same time.

Think of it! Just like you can connect to Mastodon, Facebook, Twitter (Sorry, "X" rolls eyes), Instagram, TikTok, Vine, Tumblr, Reddit, at the same time as hundreds or millions of other users, this new-fangled Unix system allowed multiple people to connect to the same operating system on the same computer at the same time. You didn't have to wait for Bob from accounting to feed his punch cards through the system any more. He could write his stupid program while your were crafting your elegant software, where it could run in parallel in all its glory!

Your buddy Jim, works at the local university, and the department there wants to do some research in cooperation with your department. The university hooked up with this whole ARPANET thing and now your system is connected to the university system via ARPANET. Both of your systems have this fancy TELNET servers. You logon to your PDP-10 system and create a new file:

.LOGIN
sos for-jim.txt
Dear Jim,

Hope things are going well!

- Me
^[s^M

Now you telnet over to Jim's server

.R TELNET
CONNECT TO UNI
@LOGIN ME
UNI AT YOUR SERVICE
>READ FILE FROM NETWRK
#NETWRK: <- DSK:for-jim.txt

Now you call Jim up on the telephone. "Hey, I just put a for-jim.txt file on your system!"

Jim logs in and runs .TYPE for-jim.txt and sees your message.

"Hahah! That's amazing!" he said, "Let me upload one to yours!". You hear some typing in the background and he finishes, "OK, check now!"

You go and login to your teletype and:

.TYPE from-jim.txt
Hey you!

TELNET is flippin' sweet! This is crazy! This is almost like regular mail,
but electronic. Here I am, writing this letter that I'm going to deliver to
you, it's almost like I'm putting it in your mailbox. Living in the future
is wild!

~Jim

The two of you chat on the phone for a little while longer - after all, it's a local call so it doesn't cost anything extra. This is some exciting stuff! You talk about the future, and start dreaming some dreams of the different things that already exist out there and how you could bring them into the digital world.

It appears that you're not the only one, though. You go to a meeting at the local uni and someone named David is there talking about their own electronic messages and some of the lessons that they've learned. Both you and Jim are mind blown at the things you learn and you can't wait to try it out. You go back to the lab there at the uni, since Jim has access. Referring to your notes from the talk, Jim creates a MAIL and MAIL.JIM subdirectory. You go and TELNET back to your work and create a MAIL dir and MAIL.ME subdir. Jim puts his first ARPANET TEXT MESSAGE in your mail dir:

From: Jim <jim@uni>
Date: Sat, 11 Oct 1997 11:56:40 -0800
To: Me <me@work>
Subject: Holy crap

This email stuff is *so* cool! The fact that we can do CC, BCC... this
changes everything!

~Jim

Over the years you have dozens or hundreds of conversations. You build mailing lists for different groups and put them in MAIL.GROUP directories. You record the different results you've had, and the experiments you set up. Some people get into arguments, some get incredibly heated.

A few years later SMTP comes on the scene and you no longer have to TELNET or FTP files around. Bob over in accounting turns out to be really excited about writing code and ends out building your first SMTP server that works shockingly well.

The university has their own, and you send the following:

From: Me <me@work>
Date: Sat, 15 Dec 1990 12:08:33 -0800
To: Jim <jim@uni>
Subject: Minnesota trip?

Hey Jim!

Are you in for the Minnesota trip? I've been exchanging some emails with a
few people out there and they were saying that some folks have a new
protocol coming out that seems super interesting! I don't know much more
beyond that... but I'm planning a road trip. You wanna come?

~Me

His response is short but sweet:

From: Jim <jim@uni>
Date: Sat, 15 Dec 1990 12:08:33 -0800
To: Me <me@work>
Subject: RE: Minnesota trip?

I'm in!
~J

The drive is pretty uneventful. You both have SuperLap laptops from Twinhead, you have been doing tons of research. You both have been married and your kids are growing up together. You've gone to recitals, sportsball games, and even taken a few family trips. You've gone from ARPANET to TCP/IP.

This one, however, is just the two of you. You make it to Minnesota and listen to a talk where this protocol called Gopher is introduced. This is super cool, and way better than FTP. Shortly after you hear about this guy named "Tim Berners-Lee" and another protocol called HTTP. Unlike Gopher, though each of these files are this new Hyper Text Markup Language or .html. And each word, or even each letter or glyph can be a distinct link.

You don't quite fully grasp it yet but you feel like this is amazing. You exchange a few emails with Jim, and one particular one unlocks it for you:

From: Jim <jim@uni>
Date: Fri, 12 Nov 1993 18:41:19 +0000
To: Me <me@work>
Subject: HTML as card catalog?

Hey, so I was thinking about HTML. Do you realize that you can link
everything? You know how you go look in the card catalog for something, and
it will direct you to different books? So you could do something like this:

<h1>600 - Technology</h1>
<ul>
    <li><a href="http://example.com/Your-Magazine-1993-vol-10">605.100 - Your Magazine - 1993, Volume 10</a><li>
</ul>

You could create an entire card catalog that way. How cool is that? But not
only can you create your card catalog - in each of the publications you can
link *directly* to the new topics. Each and every word could link. Like, I
could ask if you've heard about <a
href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zettelkasten">Zettlekasten</a> and you
could just click on that link and go directly there. Or I could write about
<a href="http://uni.example.com/jim">Jim</a> and you could go directly to
my page. That's so amazing!

I think there are some very cool opportunities for using this linking to
organize information and knowledge!

~Jim

That made it click. You can go to a new web page, you can go back and forward, creating this tree, or graph... or web of places you've visited. You can learn new things, find funny stuff out there. This is so freaking cool!

Google Invented the Internet

You're here in these early days of the web, spending hours browsing around. You've built your own work.example.com/me site. You discover that the Internet is vast. You begin to realized that it's difficult to find information you're looking for in your research. There are a lot of search engines but you've encountered sites that don't even show up in the search results. Sometimes you scroll through page after page of results before you finally find that tidbit you're looking for.

And they're slow, and often papered with ads.

And then you come across this quirky search engine with a colorful logo called "Google" and a tagline, "Don't be evil(TM)". And it was blazingly fast. You learned its advanced syntax that allowed you to find exactly what you wanted. They had a pretty novel algorithm that they called PageRank that seemed to have something to do with the way sites were linked to.

At one point when you searched, "More evil than Satan" the result was Microsoft. That was just hilarious.

Google introduced AdWords. It wasn't all that bad because they were unobtrusive ads on the side, and they actually helped a lot of smaller companies build up since they were able to target people looking for the services that they offered.

In a few years, Google quickly went from that weird niche search engine to the search engine. Their results were top notch, because they used some magic combination of the text that people linked with and how people used the Internet.

Google had buckets of cash and they bought Blogspot, and they created Google Reader that allowed you to subscribe to RSS/Atom feeds. RSS was a format created at least in part by a teenager by the name of Aaron Swartz. He also helped to build Reddit. RSS was great but like many other formats they get (ab)used incorrectly. Atom is a bit more of a rigorous feed language. Allowing users to check for updates to their favorite websites and blogs was a drastic improvement to the web.

You only had to transmit a small bit of data to know what changed on your favorite sites, and you could even just get these things delivered to your machine for offline reading on your PDA or to print out for reading on your commute to/from work.

These changes were entirely revolutionary.

There were even people called Sharebros - they were Google Reader users who had built their own social network within Google Reader. Some of them even got married! What a day to be alive!

Google continued to buy up tons of different tools and made them free to the public.

Until they started killing

The Deathwatch Beetle

The Internet was an organism, full of diversity and wonder. There were strange places and hilarious places all created by real people, doing something that they loved.

Then we started to hear the tapping.

Enter SEO. Internet, Exit Stage Left

Google used to use PageRank, with a pretty simple approach to generate search rankings. The main downside of this is that it's possible to game the system by creating buckets of fake web pages that point to the one you want -- like we saw with the "more evil" example. So Google changed a lot. Because Google was such a huge source of income -- I would bet real money that the number of people who go to google.com and type in facebook.com and click on the first link is a significant number -- Google's policies led to Search Engine Optimization and Content Marketing. The short of it is that Google started penalizing sites if you clicked the link and then returned back to Google too quickly.

In other words, if your page had easy to find, correct information it was treated exactly the same as if your page was wrong.

But if your page teased out information, giving you several pages of fluff that didn't answer the question but kept you scrolling for just enough time to finally find that outdated or entirely incorrect and now utterly useless information?

$$$$$$$

Money money money!

$$$$$$$

When I understood that, that's when I first knew that Google decided to kill the internet. I don't know, or really think it was intentional. I suspect that if you had taken anyone looking to make these changes and asked if they wanted an Internet that was less useful, more homogeneous, and siloed into social networks... I don't think they would have made that choice. Probably. Possibly.

Everything else on the Internet since then has been objectively awful.

Mostly Dead?

On the Internet of today, where there is no substance, only content and entertainment, you will find pockets of people doing people things. You can find some groups on Facebook that are heavily moderated where people are finding a community full of joy and acceptance, and people finding real community and real friendship. Not entirely unlike the Sharebros in the days of Reader.

Instead of continuing to drive people across the Internet, Google continued to aggregate power, becoming the very evil they swore to destroy.

They fed people feet first into the Facebook (who ate the formerly independent Instagram) and Twitter woodchippers. They ban "female presenting nipples" on YouTube but then give you literal pornographic ads (and when reported for violating community guidelines, Google said "Lol no, they pay us money. This porn is the good kind"). Apparently blurred nudity on your videos is also naughty, even when discussing dysentery and explosive diarrhea.

I think that the Internet is only mostly dead. Even though people consider that TikTok, Facebook/Instagram, YouTube, and maybe to some lesser extent still Twitter (sorry, X. Get rekt, Musk) to be "The Internet"...

The fact that people are still out there trying to eke out some space, they're still trying to make real connections in the face of billionaires trying to absolutely own us...

Maybe, just maybe, we're not dead yet.

Where Do We Go?

I don't claim to know where we should go from here. I can quite clearly and distinctly say:

Google killed the Internet by changing their algorithms to favor SEO, which can either be a maliciously incorrect honeypot, or accidentally or carelessly out of date. Directing us towards a fecal firehose of AI instead of improving search and rebuilding the individual, distinct Internet continues to destroy everything that is good and wholesome, driving humanity closer to extinction every day.

But I can't give specifics about where and how and exactly what to do to make things better. I have some ideas, some things that give me hope, and maybe some principles.

  1. Connection is key.
  2. Host Your Own.
  3. Slow is smooth, smooth is fast.
  4. Yeet intolerance straight into the Sun.
  5. Hansel and Gretel. Maybe that Tim Berners-Lee guy was onto something.

Connection is Key

Humanity is where it's at. You and me against the world, baby! But... really. You relationships with those around you... that's the win. Currently that's where I see people fighting back.

Host Your Own

Computers are pretty simple, actually. You can write a Gopher server in a few dozen lines of pure Python. Let's Encrypt and ZeroSSL both offer you free SSL certs. There are maybe other ones too, but those both work. You can use Caddyserver to auto get the certs for you. Outside of the scope here, but you can get those certs and use them in other servers like your SMTP/IMAP/XMPP server(s).

If you're hosting your own, as long as you have an ISP or more accurately just a TCP/IP or really any network connection that you can hook into, you can communicate. LoRa is probably too slow for most data, but... host your own.

Slow is smooth, smooth is fast

In the modern Internet there's such a huge demand for now, now, now, nownownownownownownow!!!!

Maybe we should slow down. Download your emails and reply to them offline? I don't know.

Intolerant of Intolerance

It's a paradox, but it's the only way to human.

Everybody is different from you in some way. Hippocrates said something like , "First, do no harm." Wicca teaches, "An ye harm none, do what ye will".

You're going to meet people who are different than you are. Maybe they're from Judea, while you're from Samaria.

Those differences are to be tolerated, and even celebrated! Anyone who wants to do good, and is willing to learn and change their viewpoint? Great!

Anyone who lessens someone else for what they are, or even what they do that doesn't restrict you? That's awful. That should be rejected at every single front.

In other words - every day is a good day to punch a Nazi. Fascists should be yeeted into the Sun at the earliest opportunity. You don't want a Nazi bar.

Anything else is good, though.

Hansel and Gretel

You might remember that story. They left breadcrumbs to try and make their way back (well, specifically they dropped pebbles, but they tried breadcrumbs when their awful parents tried to leave them to die). This web of links that Sir Tim Berners-Lee created?

That's flipping awesome! But there's more!

You might think that we just have something like https://www.waynewerner.com/blag/2026-11-10-00-00-google-is-killing-the-internet.html?some=useless&query and we do but we actually have way more than that.

To properly understand let's split this up

https:  //www.waynewerner.com  /blag/2026-11-10-00-00-google-is-killing-the-internet.html  ?some=useless&query

We have:

There are a bit more details but if you think of these things as an atomic value you're missing a very lot of power here. That protocol can be anything. There are several ones that are reserved and well-behaved clients will understand in a certain way, but there's no law that says you have to treat anything in any way.

If you use ActivityPub, or Mastodon, it does use http(s). But there's nothing to stop you from creating a client that understands mastodon:@ketmorco@fosstodon.org as going to https://fosstodon.org/@ketmorco. Or maybe mastodon:@ketmorco@fosstodon.org?dm means that you should DM me. Or whatever you hecking want, I'm not your dad. Unless you're one of my offspring, in which case, "Hi kids!"

Anyway, you can totally link to stuff all over the place. And you should. Because you want to remember how to get there from here.

I'm a huge fan of using links, and linking to topics, as well as using ag to search, though grep is pretty good, too. And if you use WaynesWiki then you have a leg up.

Anyway...

I don't know what the answer is. But what we have right now, in November of 2026 is broken.

^C


Home | Blag Index

This site is Copyleft Wayne Werner - BY-NC-SA 4.0